Leftover Easter Candy Cookies
Posted in Cookies, Dessert on April 29th, 2011 by admin – 1 CommentNow that Easter’s over I see that there are a billion and one articles and recipes with uses leftover Easter candy. But I found this recipe before Easter and had to try it, so much that I went out and bought candy explicitly intended to be leftover Easter candy.
I know the point is to use up what you already have, or buy it on clearance the next day, but I didn’t want to risk there being nothing left except rows of Peeps and pastel candy corn. I picked out some candy that seemed like it would make the least scary cookies (no Peeps) – Whoppers robin eggs, Starburst sour jelly beans, and the ultimate, Dove peanut butter eggs.

I won’t lie—I was aware that these cookies had the potential to be either awful or awesome.
I agree.
Ingredients:
- 1 cup butter
- 2 cups sugar
- 2 eggs
- 1/2 cup milk
- 3 1/2 cups flour
- 1 teaspoon baking soda
- 1 teaspoon salt
- Anywhere from 1 to 1 1/2 cups leftover Easter candy
I realized quickly that this would make a lot of (potentially frightening) cookies so I cut the recipe in half easily.
Directions:
- In a large bowl, mix together the flour, baking soda and salt; set aside.
- Mix butter and sugar until light and fluffy; add the eggs, one at a time, mixing well after each addition.
So this didn’t say anything about softening the butter first, and I remembered I can do this the easy way now.

However I’d recommend softening the butter a bit first. I actually made the mixer jump a couple times trying to mix a solid block of butter into the sugar. But no physical labor on my end!
- Stir in your milk until incorporated.
My milk wasn’t really incorporating so I moved on to the next step and hoped for the best.
- Stir the flour mixture in bit by bit, swiping down the sides of the bowl, until fully incorporated.

Incorporated.
- Fold in your Easter candy.
I divided my dough into two bowls because was I imagining two different kinds of cookies coming out of this. The first I mixed in the jellybeans and malted eggs.

The second I mixed in chopped up peanut butter eggs.

- Let the dough chill for at least one hour.
I missed this step at the start, which explained why my dough was so gooey when I tried to scoop my first cookie. So I jumped in the shower while waiting and put on my Cooking Naked apron to finish. You can add this to the list of things I promise not to do when I’m baking professionally – I won’t be naked in the kitchen, apron or not – however if you’re on my personal Christmas list you might want to specify no naked cookies.
- Heat the oven to 400°F.
- Using a cookie scoop, drop cookies about 2 inches apart on a lightly greased (or parchment-lined) baking sheet.
I have this cheap cookie scoop that was a silly impulse buy years ago.

While scooping I noticed a small hole forming in the plastic bit. Great, I thought, an excuse to buy a fancy new one. The hole never got bigger so now I’m thinking it was designed
that way all along, but still… excuse to buy fancy new one?

- Bake 8 to 10 minutes, or until almost no imprint remains when touched lightly.
I really expected the peanut butter egg ones to be the ultimate cookie but they were kind of disappointing. I don’t think the base cookie batter was that interesting, but the weird candy ones made up for it and were surprisingly better than expected.

I took them to work, put a label on the container that said “scary cookies” and still every single one was eaten and complimented. I’ve realized that the free food aspect adds a 20% or so bonus to the perception of tastiness so free samples are definitely the way to go when it comes to promoting my bakery.

I wouldn’t rule out the idea of making these again, but only if I had actual leftover candy to use up. I would also invest in the parchment paper because I still have this mess to figure out how to clean:
That’s my good cookie sheet too…
Now the next problem is what to do with all of this leftover Easter candy cookie candy?




She can perfect her sleepy, I’ve-been-here-alllll-day look in under 30 seconds.

Recommend serving with plum sake.
Just… tapioca.




But a pretty picture it did make.
The rice was ready long before either of us were.

Yellow.

Really I’ve been looking for an excuse to use this picture for something for years.


